Enjoy a free mini duo when you spend £25 | 20% off when you buy 2 brow products! *Exclusions apply

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

Customer Reviews

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner Customer Reviews

GBP 16.0

£16.00

Overall Rating : 4.36 / 5 (22 Reviews)

22 Reviews

  • 15 5 star reviews
  • 3 4 star reviews
  • 2 3 star reviews
  • 1 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews

Quantity

( 0 item in your basket items in your basket )

Other customers bought:

Overall Rating : 4.36 / 5 (22 Reviews)

22 Reviews

  • 15 5 star reviews
  • 3 4 star reviews
  • 2 3 star reviews
  • 1 2 star reviews
  • 1 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

Really wanted to like this product

2

I have oily eyes (yum) so I can forgive the fact this liner doesn't last all that long for me. However, and it's quite a big however, I just hate the way it looks. It's grey and flat, again forgivable, but what I really cannot forgive is the way it bleeds. And it doesn't seem to matter how I set it (triple powder and Urban Decay primer). Still I get little bleedy lines crossing into my nice clean eye shadow. I won't be buying again - the search for the perfect liner continues.

Report this review

The only eyeliner I’ll use

5

This eyeliner has the perfect brush for achieving anything from sharp, fine line to a bold, thick cat eye. The staying power is great, I’ve cried wearing it many times and it’s stayed out. I’ve even gone to sleep with my makeup on and I wake up in the morning and it’s still there! I’ve bought so many of these over the years and my only comment would be that the last one I purchased doesn’t seem to be as black and needs building up. It might just be a dodgy batch, hopefully the formula hasn’t been changed!

Report this review

Makeup staple

4

This eyeliner is easy to apply and generally has good coverage in terms of colour. I like the thinner application as this stops the eyeliner rubbing off quickly. I can also apply closer to my eye for a neater 'wing'. It's not 5 star as it does wear off over the day and you need to reapply.

Report this review

Amazing eyeliner

5

I have tried so many eyeliners and by far this the best quality and affordable price 

Report this review

Love this eyeliner

5

Always struggled with liquid eyeliner but this glides on so precisely, perfect!

Report this review

Nightmare to remove

3

This liner started so promisingly. Smooth application,and amazing staying power. However, after a few goes, the application is no longer smooth. This is despite me storing it upright and giving it a good shake prior to use. The worse thing about this liner is the removal. I used an oil based remover but even so, the liner is kind of solid, and breaks apart in tiny clumps. There are literally hundreds of tiny pieces getting into your eyes, until you step into the shower and wash them out. For that reason alone, I don't recommend this liner. Complete waste of money.

Report this review

Good product

4

Bit fiddly to use at first but a good product. Is lasting longer than the thicker tip product which runs out in a matter of a few weeks. But not as easy to apply.

Report this review

Good points and Bad

3

I am on the fence about this product. Good points: - Fab colour Glides on amazingly Lovely intense colour Bad points:- Not that waterproof Smudges and leaks after a few hours of wear. I am a girl who only likes to do her make-up once a day. I purposely only buy products that will stay in place and not fade during the day. My absolute bug bare is when  an eyeliner leaks and smudges after a days wear and I end up getting panda eyes! I am finding this eye liner does this - only a little, but enough to niggle me. It's a shame because if it stayed in place this would be PERFECT. The colour is amazing and in in goes on like a dream. I haven't tried this in water but, if it leaks and smudges after a few hours, I don't hold out much  hope in water.   

Report this review

Extremely disappointed

1

Dried up so early I cant remember if I ever had a single smooth application. Let down by this product. Cannot even say that I've used this (tried to) 10 times and the brush is completely dried up and bristles dispersed. In all honesty I'm completely baffled by the positive reviews

Report this review

Really intense colour, great definition.

5

I really like this product because of the intensity of its black colour, which makes the eye look much more professional and beautiful. The brush shape is not difficult to use, it actually allows you to create the line you want due to its flexibility.

Report this review